Judge’s Decision on Disputed Ballots
In a milestone event, State Supreme Court Judge James Walsh has announced that Republican Charles “Chuck” Marshall won the latest Saratoga Springs special election for Commissioner of Public Works. Late Friday, the circuit judge’s ruling led the attorney for Saratoga Springs Democrats to seek an appeal.
The outcome of the election hinged on determining the validity of many write-in ballots cast for Democratic candidate Hank Kuczynski. Judge Walsh voided a large number of these ballots, stating they had been filled out inappropriately. The specific reasons for disqualification included:
- Voters writing “Democrat” or “Dem” in boxes next to the write-in area.
- Excessive markings beyond the designated write-in space.
- Kuczynski’s name appearing multiple times in additional spaces on the ballot.
Due to these discrepancies, 93 of the 106 contested ballots were excluded, effectively ensuring Marshall’s victory by approximately 85 votes.
Democratic Response and Possible Appeal
The ruling has raised concerns for Sarah Burger, the attorney representing Saratoga Springs Democrats, who emphasized the importance of respecting voter intent.
“We continue to argue that any ballots that say ‘Hank Kuczynski’ in the write-in box should be counted for Hank Kuczynski. Otherwise, it is voter suppression,” she stated.
Burger further noted that an appeal is being considered to challenge the disqualification of these ballots.
Implications for the Saratoga Springs City Council
This election outcome could bring significant political changes to the Saratoga Springs City Council.
- If Marshall’s victory stands, Republicans will gain a majority for the first time in a generation.
- If Kuczynski had won, Democrats would have retained control of the council.
The ruling could reshape the city’s governance and impact future policies.
Next Steps
The official certification of the election results remains pending as the Democratic Party deliberates on an appeal.
Republican County Board of Elections Commissioner Joe Suhrada has confirmed that the board will delay certification until any appeals are resolved.
FAQ
Why were ballots most often rejected?
Ballots were disqualified due to:
- Extraneous markings
- Writing outside designated areas
- Filling in the candidate’s name multiple times
Will they appeal the judge’s ruling?
Yes, the Saratoga Springs Democrats’ attorney has stated they are considering an appeal.
How does this election affect the City Council’s balance?
If the ruling stands, Republicans will gain a majority on the Saratoga Springs City Council for the first time in decades.
When will the election results be certified?
The certification process is currently on hold pending the potential appeal process.
What are your thoughts on this ruling? Share your opinions on how this decision could impact the political landscape of Saratoga Springs!
